Happy Friday! Last year, I made several cookie-themed milkshakes including Circus Animal Cookie Milkshakes, Oreo Milkshakes, and Edible Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Milkshakes … but I realized I left a cookie out! Nutter Butters! So I came up with this delicious, over-the-top Nutter Butter and Jelly Milkshake!
I love Nutter Butters! I never had even tried one for years, but only started eating them when my marathon training group would hand them out to the runners when we were doing long 10+ mile runs. I guess they would hand them out because peanut butter has protein and there’s sodium in them? I don’t know, but, regardless, they are delicious! And so when I was brainstorming for this milkshake, I realized it was a no-brainer to make a play on a peanut butter and jelly sandwich and make a Nutter Butter and Jelly milkshake. So it’s a grape jelly milkshake with peanut butter frosting and grape jelly swirled in the glasses, the glass rim is garnished with a generous helping of peanut butter frosting and decorated with Nutter Butter Minis, then the milkshake is topped with whipped cream, regular Nutter Butter cookie and a mini cookie and a dollop of grape jelly!
Here’s the recipe: